HomeSportsSimon Doull's Concerns for Young Indian Batters on Spin-Friendly Pitches

Simon Doull’s Concerns for Young Indian Batters on Spin-Friendly Pitches

Former New Zealand cricketer and commentator Simon Doull expressed concerns about the challenges modern Indian batters face, especially on spin-friendly pitches. In an exclusive chat with Hindustan Times, Doull discussed the ongoing debate over the nature of Test pitches in India, emphasizing the need for balanced wickets that test both batsmen and bowlers. While acknowledging the importance of challenging conditions, he raised questions about how emerging talents like Shubman Gill and Yashasvi Jaiswal would fare on such surfaces.

1. Criticism of Indian Pitches

  • Historical Context: The debate over Indian pitches has been ongoing, with England’s last series win in India dating back to 2012. Recent years have seen scrutiny over spin-friendly surfaces, challenging the visiting teams.
  • Rohit Sharma’s Stance: Indian captain Rohit Sharma expressed dissatisfaction with the criticism of pitches, emphasizing the fairness of conditions that test the skills of both batsmen and bowlers.

2. Simon Doull’s Perspective on Pitches

  • Pitch Standards: Simon Doull emphasized the importance of fresh and well-maintained pitches, asserting that it doesn’t matter whether the ball turns or moves on the first day, as long as the surface is prepared appropriately.
  • Balanced Wickets: The commentator defended India’s right to play to their strengths at home but stressed the need for a pitch that is not underprepared, rough, or ordinary on the opening day, promoting a fair contest.

3. Concerns for Young Indian Batters

  • Simon Doull’s Worry: While supporting India’s home advantage, Doull expressed concerns about the new-age Indian batters, including Shubman Gill and Yashasvi Jaiswal. He questioned how these players would achieve Test double hundreds on challenging pitches.
  • Comparisons to Past Players: Simon Doull highlighted the contrast between the careers of previous Indian batting legends like Tendulkar, Dravid, Sehwag, and Laxman, who played on different surfaces, and the expectations for modern players.

4. Performance Analysis of Young Batters

Simon Doull Yashasvi Jaiswal Shubman Gill
Pic Credit: Google
  • Shubman Gill: Despite a promising start in white-ball cricket, Gill’s Test average remains modest at 30.59 in 20 appearances. Doull pointed out Gill’s struggles on spin-friendly Indian pitches, questioning his ability to replicate the success of past legends.
  • Yashasvi Jaiswal: Jaiswal, yet to play a home Test, made his debut in challenging conditions in the West Indies and South Africa. Doull raised concerns about the adaptability of young batters to spin-friendly tracks.

5. Doull’s Views on England’s Approach

Simon Doull
Pic Credit: Google
  • Aggressive Approach: Doull acknowledged England’s aggressive approach in Test cricket, describing it as attractive and a resurgence of the format. However, he questioned the sustainability of this approach over a five-Test series against India.
  • Predictions for Series: While anticipating an entertaining Test series, Doull doubted England’s ability to maintain their aggressive style throughout, predicting a challenging competition against the formidable Indian side.


Simon Doull’s insights shed light on the complexities surrounding the nature of Test pitches in India and the challenges faced by emerging talents. The concerns raised about the adaptability of young Indian batters on spin-friendly tracks add an intriguing dimension to the ongoing discussions about home advantage and pitch conditions in international cricket. As India gears up for the series against England, the performance of players like Shubman Gill and Yashasvi Jaiswal will be closely watched, offering a glimpse into the future of Indian cricket.

Also Read – Rajat Patidar’s Remarkable Journey to India’s Test Squad